President Trump’s decision to remove JD Vance from negotiations with Iran may be raising questions about the vice president’s political future, but some good government groups are hailing Trump’s decision to have Vance focus on his position as “fraud czar.”
Trump has made cracking down on waste and abuse one of his signature policies. But the administration’s anti-fraud efforts – including the Department of Government Efficiency, created in 2025, and the Task Force to Eliminate Fraud, established in March – have been marked by poorly executed directives and difficult-to-verify claims.
“It definitely hasn’t been front and center to this point, and instead more a matter of scattered press conferences and an agency here and there with something,” said Matt Weidinger of the American Enterprise Institute.

Government watchdog groups hope that Vance’s streamlined portfolio will provide a necessary reset for what they see as long-overdue policy changes. They also note that it is easier to assail fraud, waste, and abuse than to root it out. Fraud in federal programs has remained a thorny problem for decades, raging on despite scattershot efforts to combat it from inspectors general, congressional committees, and the like. The same is true for waste, which usually takes the form of improper government payments.
The Government Accountability Office estimates that the federal government loses between $233 billion and $521 billion annually to fraud, based on data from fiscal years 2018 through 2022. Improper payments – especially overpayments – are another persistent problem, though they are not necessarily fraudulent. Agencies reported an estimated $186 billion in improper payments in fiscal 2025.
Recovery efforts recoup only a fraction of those losses, experts told RealClearInvestigations. They cited the expense of prosecuting smaller cases, the difficulty of recovering money from perpetrators who flee or move assets, and limited coordination among federal agencies and law enforcement authorities. The government is also loath to dun citizens for overpayments they received through little or no fault of their own.
To change this, Trump is adopting a whole-of-government approach that, if successful, might burnish Vance’s political prospects following bruising midterm defeats. Failure, on the other hand, could saddle a potential Vance campaign as Kamala Harris was by her ineffective stint as the Biden administration’s “border czar.”
“At a minimum, the task force is a good idea because it puts fraud in the public conversation and shows the president is taking it seriously,” said Jeremy Portnoy, an investigator with the non-profit OpenTheBooks, which seeks transparency in all government spending. “Trump certainly talks about fraud more than most other presidents and that in itself is a positive.”
For now, it remains unclear whether Vance’s role will yield measurable results or political benefits. “So far it hasn’t been the albatross some predicted for Vance, and if it succeeded it could still be to his credit,” Weidinger told RCI.
Big guns, scattered shots
Trump has rolled out some of his biggest guns to battle fraud, waste, and abuse – creating the Elon Musk-led DOGE in 2025, and then tapping Vance last spring to head the anti-fraud effort.
But the task force, composed of representatives of every Cabinet-level department except the Department of Defense, along with some agencies with fraud issues such as the Small Business Administration, was bogged down by both political opposition from Democrats and its own inefficiency.

Trump’s executive order creating the task force last March gave departments and agencies 30-day and 60-day deadlines to submit “descriptions of such transactions and processes and suggested measures to prevent such fraud,” and directed the task force itself “to adopt, as appropriate, minimum anti-fraud requirements for transactions and processes.”
Trump administration officials told RCI that all the deadlines had been met. However, some six months after their latest due dates, none of the plans are available for public review.
The lack of public plans makes it difficult to assess the task force’s progress, Weidinger and others said. By way of comparison, when President Biden requested a “whole of government” approach to diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives, the bureaucracy appeared to respond with alacrity, and something similar should have happened via the Anti-Fraud Task Force, they said.
“If the government is doing something, they should be telling the people,” said Tom Schatz, president of Citizens Against Government Waste. “That’s what you would normally do running a business.”
In addition to a lack of transparency, the administration’s anti-fraud efforts have been bedeviled by fuzzy math. In June, for example, Education Secretary Linda McMahon said, “Our efforts prevented more than $1 billion in student aid fraud,” after the House passed a bill to fight back against “ghost students” getting federal loans.
“But no one could give us any data or the math on that,” Portnoy said. “I can’t say it isn’t true, just that no one has been able to substantiate it.”
Similarly, after the House Committee on Energy and Commerce released a report on Medicaid and Medicare fraud weeks before the midterms, it featured a pull quote from Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. saying that the Biden administration had cut program oversight to the bone while spending was skyrocketing to some $2.2 trillion per year.
“Yeah, I mean the most shocking thing to me was the Biden administration opening the door to waste, fraud, and abuse,” Kennedy testified in April. “We had a program integrity office. There were 80 people in it, which was not enough to cover 50 states and three territories. They fired immediately all but six of them. So we have no program integrity department.”
Neither the House committee nor the Department of Health and Human Services, however, could back up the secretary’s assertion in response to RCI’s questions. A spokesperson for CMS did not provide an answer to RCI’s question about Kennedy’s reference but insisted “program integrity remains a core priority.” A committee spokesperson said they could not vouch for Kennedy’s figures.

The website for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services still lists a “Center for Program Integrity,” with a director, an annual budget of $1 billion and more than 500 employees. The Center’s principal deputy, Jeneen Iwugo, did not respond to RCI’s request for comment on whether the office had been shorthanded for a time, or if its oversight duties have been transferred elsewhere in the department.
Nevertheless, fraud experts said the Biden administration had relaxed some oversight requirements, while emphasizing that the Trump administration had not substantiated its numerical claims.
“There’s a lot of evidence the Biden administration pulled back on oversight, that it relaxed guardrails, paused eligibility checks and the like,” said Jeremy Nighohossian, a senior fellow at the Competitive Enterprise Institute who focuses on healthcare. “But a lot of the time the Trump administration can’t back up any of the numbers it gives, and there doesn’t seem to be any substantiation.”
More fuzzy math
The sketchy math claims extend to other calculations. The task force maintains the Fraud Ledger, which presents the administration’s claimed anti-fraud accomplishments. As of Nov. 17, the Ledger claims $391.6 billion in fraud that has been “uncovered,” “stopped,” or “enforced,” though again that total includes the 13 months before the Task Force formed. And projections on what fraud might be prevented have a ring like the “jobs saved” statistic invented by the Obama administration, and not everyone is convinced all the numbers are real. “Lots of estimates of fraud are just that – estimates that are never formally established,” Weidinger said.
Fraud “stopped,” for example, counts $72 billion “saved annually through administrative actions such as provider suspensions and rule changes.” In other words, that’s a projected figure – a highly subjective one at that – and because the Task Force is an executive creation and many of the Trump administration’s proposals were not codified, a future Democratic administration could end them.
Other media outlets have exposed weaknesses in the ledger, and since DOGE began its work in 2025, some have found an inability to back up all its figures independently. And the ledger doesn’t always move in the direction one might expect, which would be for the figures for fraud to grow in all three categories. On Sept. 27, for instance, The New York Times ran what it called a “fact check” on the ledger and at that point its total for “enforced,” meaning “indictments, settlements and financial fines,” was at $59.1 billion. Yet on Nov. 17, that total had fallen to $58.9 billion, indicating something went awry with previous estimates.
The case of the Small Business Administration also illustrates the problems with nailing down amounts of fraud. The SBA inspector general had estimated that of the $1.2 trillion it distributed as COVID relief via its Paycheck Protection Program and Economic Injury Disaster Loans, $200 billion was siphoned by fraudsters through fictional businesses, inflated payrolls, and the like. The Fraud Ledger, however, credits $146.8 billion in fraud across three categories to the SBA (which still gives it the biggest total of all departments and agencies listed).
Recovery blues
Another oddity is that no matter how precise the government’s figures are for detected or prosecuted fraud, the amounts recovered are always but a fraction of the total. Experts cited the increasing sophistication of foreign criminal organizations that target federal spending as a major obstacle to recovering stolen funds.
“In recent years, the number one reason has to be because the fraud was perpetrated by overseas criminal gangs and they didn’t wait around for the good guys to find out and try to recover it,” Weidinger said. “An estimated 70 percent of fraud involving pandemic unemployment benefits was due to overseas actors.”

Schatz noted that recovering that money is complicated for other reasons. In the case of COVID money, the statutes of limitations have expired in some cases, and an effort to extend them failed in Congress. Earlier, Congress cut the practice of Recovery Audit Contractors, who had some success in health care fraud recovery, after hospitals and other major employers complained to their elected representatives.
Since the Task Force launched, however, the administration has implemented some changes. CMS has reached out to its contractors to find “innovative ideas from the industry” to combat fraud. The agency has also made more of its data publicly available. This has unleashed a coterie of citizen sleuths, many of whom use powerful AI tools to scour the mountains of data.
Meanwhile, the SBA has opened new hotlines for reporting fraud. In May, the Justice Department unveiled data-driven “FOCUS” teams to root out fraud, and its National Fraud Detection Center launched in August.
Citizen sleuths
The results of these initiatives remain to be seen, and government officials are still sorting thinly sourced leads from legitimate targets in the flood of new information, some private investigators told RCI. Turning suggestions of fraud into cases that can be prosecuted is often time-consuming and expensive.
In addition, officials need to separate money lost through fraud from that lost by improper payments, which often go to hospitals and other legitimate businesses as well as individuals. Improper payments have cost taxpayers some $3 trillion since fiscal year 2003, and the $186 billion in improper payments the government made in FY2025 was an increase of $24 billion from the previous fiscal year, according to the GAO’s estimate.
In the end, experts say the most important work for the Task Force is wrenching the federal bureaucracy away from its usual patterns with fraud. Rather than “pay and chase,” where the government must first identify fraudulent activity in money spent and then spend more money chasing it, the programs need better checks to avoid spending the money in the first place.
White House officials acknowledged that, thus far, many of the anti-fraud measures are temporary, but said two factors, which could be slotted under “business as usual” in the Capitol, have worked against the Task Force from the outset.
One is a frustration with Congress, which has been reluctant to add anti-fraud measures to its spending bills. Nighohossian pointed to some legislative progress. He said last year’s “One Big Beautiful Bill” installed more frequent eligibility checks on Medicaid that “will be much harder for a Democratic administration to undo.” The House committee’s April report on fraud in Medicaid and Medicare did make 37 recommendations for how CMS could improve its efforts to combat fraud, all of which, the committee said, the Centers agreed with. In August, five months after Trump issued his anti-fraud executive order, Vance hosted a congressional “roundtable” event, but with the midterm results it seems highly unlikely the lame-duck Republican majority will make any moves before surrendering power in January.
A bigger problem than Congress, however, is the tremendous inertia built into the federal bureaucracy, according to several officials familiar with the Task Force’s work. For decades, they said, many federal agencies have operated on autopilot. The Trump administration is the first to set up a framework to address the problem seriously, according to Task Force officials. Finally, officials want agencies to work harder to prevent fraudulent payments rather than rely on “pay and chase” – detecting fraud after money has gone out and then trying to recover it.

Much of the spending on major entitlements like Medicaid and Medicare, moreover, is administered by the states, which vary greatly in how seriously they care about fraud. Officials say the federal government must work more closely with them to implement stronger safeguards against fraudulent and improper payments.
“Medicaid services are not always designed with program integrity in mind,” the House report said, and “continue(d) reliance on reactive program integrity rather than preventive oversight” was one of the main culprits behind the tens of billions lost in fraud each year.
Schatz, who has been on Capitol Hill since 1986, said those are genuine issues. While flares go up from time to time when a scandal erupts, there has never been a comprehensive and sustained effort to change the way federal programs operate. If the Task Force accomplishes nothing more than a cooperative network to combat fraud between federal agencies, prosecutors, and state and local law enforcement, that would provide a lasting benefit.
Such a network would also show that Washington recognizes the need for sustained attention rather than responses driven by headlines, Schatz said. Because fraud harms taxpayers and intended beneficiaries, efforts to combat it should draw bipartisan support, he said.
“There seems to be a public acknowledgment that it’s OK to fix it,” he said. “It seems to me that should transcend administrations or whoever is in power in Congress.”
Support RealClear
We're proud to make our journalism accessible to everyone, but producing high-quality investigative pieces still comes at a cost.
That's why we need your help. By making a contribution today, you'll be supporting RealClearInvestigations and ensuring that we can keep providing in-depth reporting that holds the powerful accountable.
Click here to make a tax-deductible donation.
Thank you!